7 Best Wishlist by Square App Alternatives for Shopify

Looking for a Wishlist by Square Alternative?

Wishlist by Square is a popular Shopify app for guest wishlists, save buttons, a shareable wishlist page and saved-item reports.

However, the app sends shoppers no emails. Saved products get no reminders, price-drop alerts or back-in-stock alerts, and each shopper keeps only one list.

To help you find the right alternative, we've compared the seven best Wishlist by Square app alternatives based on app type, features, customization, pricing, AI capabilities, and the number of additional apps included in the same subscription.

Since Vitals is our app and one of the alternatives, we've also highlighted its limitations.

What Is the Wishlist by Square App?

Wishlist by Square is a free Shopify app for save buttons, guest wishlists and a wishlist page. It lets merchants add hearts to product cards, keep guests' saves without an account and see which products shoppers save most.

Here's what you can do with the Wishlist by Square app:

• Save buttons: Show a full-width Add to Wishlist button or an inline heart beside Add to cart on the product page. Hearts also show on product cards on home, collection, search and vendor pages.
• Guest wishlists: Let shoppers save with no account. Guest lists stay in a browser cookie for 365 days, and logged-in lists sync across devices.
• Wishlist page: Give shoppers a page where they add saved items to the cart one by one or all at once. The page shows a low-stock label, and a header icon counts the saved items.
• Sharing: Let shoppers share a wishlist by link or email. Shared lists open on their own shared wishlist page.
• Data and languages: See the top 10 saved products and live events, and export every saved item as a CSV. The app shows in 16 languages.

How Much Does the Wishlist by Square App Cost?

The Wishlist by Square app has a single Free plan with every feature and no paid plan, so there's no pricing table for it. Prices from square-apps.com on October 16, 2026.

Why Shopify Merchants Look for Wishlist by Square Alternatives

The Wishlist by Square app holds a 5.0 rating from 134 reviews and carries the Built for Shopify badge. Still, some merchants switch to another app for these reasons:

• No reminder emails: The app sends shoppers no emails. Saved items get no reminders or price-drop alerts.
• No restock alerts: Shoppers can't ask to hear when a sold-out product returns. That needs a separate back-in-stock app.
• One list per shopper: Each shopper keeps a single wishlist. There are no named lists or gift registry.
• No email platform connection: The app has no Klaviyo or other email platform connection.

If any of these sound familiar, an all-in-one app alternative may suit your store better.

Read: Best Wishlist Apps for Shopify Stores in 2026

How We Compared the Wishlist by Square Alternatives

We reviewed each app's Shopify App Store listing, help docs and changelog (where available) on October 16, 2026. All ratings and review counts come from the listings on that day.

We compared the apps on:

• App type: standalone or all-in-one
• Features: save buttons, guest wishlists, sharing, the wishlist page, shopper alerts and data export
• Customization: where the hearts and save buttons show, from the product page and collection grids to the header, cart and customer account
• Pricing: plan prices, free trial length and any usage charges
• AI capabilities: AI tools and MCP support
• Additional apps: how many additional apps each one includes in the same subscription

Short Answer

Vitals - All in One App is the best Wishlist by Square alternative for most stores.

• It offers a wishlist plus back-in-stock alerts by email or text and a recently viewed carousel, while the Wishlist by Square app focuses on the wishlist alone
• It includes 40+ apps, such as bundles, discounts and reviews, in one subscription from $29.99/month
• It replaces multiple single-purpose apps you'd otherwise install and pay for one by one each month

What Are the Top Wishlist by Square Alternatives for Shopify in 2026?

Here's a quick overview of each app. You'll find what each one can and can't do in the reviews below.

1. Vitals - All in One App

Best for: Stores that want 40+ apps, including Wishlist, Back in Stock, Pop-ups and Product Reviews, in one subscription

Rating: 4.9 (2,992 reviews) | App type: All-in-one | Free trial: 7 days | Built for Shopify: Yes

Vitals is an all-in-one Shopify app that offers a wishlist plus 40+ apps under one subscription, starting at $29.99/month.

With the Vitals Wishlist App, you can add hearts to product cards and the main product photo, plus a full-width or inline Add to Wishlist button. You can also see which products shoppers save most and export every saved item as a CSV. Guests can save without signing up, and logged-in customers can see the same list on every device.

Beyond the wishlist, Vitals offers email and push campaigns, a spin the wheel pop-up, product reviews and 40+ apps in one subscription, so you don't have to install and pay for each app separately.

Key features:

• Hearts on product cards in collection, search and home page grids, and over the main product photo
• A full-width Add to Wishlist button, or a compact heart on the same line as Add to cart
• A saved-items counter on the header heart
• Guest saves with no account, kept in the browser for a year
• One list across devices once a customer logs in
• A wishlist page where shoppers add one saved product or all of them to the cart
• Sharing by copy link or email
• A Wishlist page next to Orders and Profile in Shopify's new customer accounts
• Your most-saved products, an Events log and a CSV export
• Back-in-stock alerts by email or text from Vitals Back in Stock App

Pros:

• Review stars from Vitals Product Reviews App beside each saved product
• No limit on how many products shoppers save
• Vitals MCP, to ask Claude or ChatGPT about what shoppers save and never buy
• 40+ apps under one plan. Crystal Pro Jewellery swapped 7 single-purpose apps for one Vitals subscription

Cons:

• Sends no wishlist emails, such as reminders or price-drop alerts
• Restock emails go out in the one language you write them in

Pricing:

Prices from vitals.app/pricing on October 31, 2026, with a 7-day free trial and no usage charges on any plan.

Read: Best Back in Stock Apps for Shopify in 2026

2. Wishlist Hero

Best for: Stores that want the wishlist app itself to email price drops and low stock, and to send events to ad pixels

Rating: 4.7 (416 reviews) | App type: Standalone | Free trial: 14 days | Built for Shopify: No

Wishlist Hero is a Shopify app from Revamp for wishlists and wishlist emails. Its biggest strength is reminder emails, with price-drop and low-stock messages sent to shoppers who saved an item. Shoppers hear about a saved product just as it gets cheaper or nearly sells out, so the wishlist keeps pulling them back. Its paid plans also pass wishlist events to Meta Pixel, GA4 and TikTok Pixel for ad audiences. It's a strong choice if you retarget shoppers based on what they saved.

Key features:

• Save buttons as a heart, star or bookmark on product pages, collection grids, search results and quick views
• A floating launch point plus a header icon with a count
• A wishlist shown as a pop-up or on its own page
• Guest saves merged into the account at login, plus variant-level saves
• Price-drop and low-stock emails with editable templates and test sends (Silver plan)
• Meta Pixel, GA4, TikTok Pixel and Klaviyo onsite events (Silver plan)
• Sending through Mailchimp, SendGrid, Klaviyo or Omnisend, plus a REST API (Gold Plus plan)
• Reports on top products, top customers and email rates, with CSV exports

Pros:

• Shopper emails about price drops and low stock
• Wishlist events for TikTok as well as Meta and GA4
• Plans that scale to 100,000 additions a month

Cons:

• Saves stop for the rest of the month once a plan's quota is reached, unless the store upgrades
• Revamp's uninstall guide lists theme files to remove by hand
• Focuses on wishlists and wishlist emails
• Back-in-stock alerts are a separate Revamp app

Pricing:

Prices from revampco.com on October 16, 2026, with a 14-day free trial. The App Store listing shows only three of these plans.

Alternatives: 8 Best Wishlist Hero App Alternatives for Shopify

3. Wishlist by Flits

Best for: Stores selling products in many variants that want back-in-stock alerts inside the wishlist app

Rating: 5.0 (7 reviews) | App type: Standalone | Free trial: 14 days | Built for Shopify: Yes

Wishlist by Flits is a Shopify app for variant-level wishlists and restock emails. What sets it apart is its Notify Me emails, sent when a sold-out variant returns. Shoppers who saved a sold-out size or colour hear when it's back, so restock alerts don't need a second app. Flits launched it in February 2026 after splitting the wishlist away from its loyalty app. It suits stores selling products in many sizes or colours.

Key features:

• A one-click save button for guests, with a pop-up for picking the exact variant
• Collections of saved items and shareable wishlists
• Notify Me back-in-stock emails, 2,500 a month on Unlimited
• Save for Later from the cart, plus Saved for later on checkout for Shopify Plus stores
• Saved items sent to Klaviyo and Omnisend
• Custom SVG icons, custom CSS and wishlists inside customer accounts

Pros:

• Restock emails inside the wishlist app
• Klaviyo sync without a second app
• More than one list per shopper
• Unlimited wishlist actions on every plan

Cons:

• Has seven reviews in total, all since February 2026
• No price-drop or low-stock alerts that we could find
• Focuses on wishlists and restock emails

Pricing:

Prices from getflits.com on October 16, 2026, with a 14-day free trial.

Alternatives: 7 Best Wishlist by Flits App Alternatives for Shopify

4. Swish (Wishlist King)

Best for: Stores on Klaviyo that want restock, low-stock and price-drop flows built from saved items

Rating: 4.9 (288 reviews) | App type: Standalone | Free trial: 30 days | Built for Shopify: Yes

Swish, formerly Wishlist King, is a Shopify app for wishlists that feed Klaviyo. Where it stands out is alert events, with restock, low-stock and price-drop triggers passed to Klaviyo at thresholds you set. Your own Klaviyo flows then email shoppers about their saved items, so wishlist alerts match the rest of your email. Shoppers can also keep several named lists. If Klaviyo already sends your email, it's a good fit.

Key features:

• An app block on the product page, collection buttons and a floating wishlist link
• Guest lists kept in the browser and linked to the account on login
• Named lists, such as one per occasion
• Klaviyo events for back in stock, low stock and price drops, with set thresholds
• Wishlist welcome and reminder flows in Klaviyo
• A sign-up prompt that turns wishlist visitors into customer accounts
• GA4 and Meta Pixel tracking
• Hydrogen, Tapcart and a read and write API

Pros:

• Alert emails based on saved items, sent through Klaviyo
• Several named lists per shopper
• Support for Hydrogen and Tapcart stores

Cons:

• Needs Klaviyo to send any alert
• Price follows the store's Shopify plan, up to $99 a month on Shopify Plus
• Focuses on the wishlist and its Klaviyo events

Pricing:

Prices from swish.app on October 16, 2026, with a 30-day free trial. Each plan matches a Shopify plan, and all of them include every feature.

Alternatives: 8 Best Swish (Wishlist King) App Alternatives for Shopify

5. SWishlist: Simple Wishlist

Best for: Multilingual stores that only want shoppers to save and share products

Rating: 4.9 (112 reviews) | App type: Standalone | Free trial: No | Built for Shopify: No

SWishlist: Simple Wishlist is a Shopify app by SoluCommerce for saving products and sharing lists. It's strongest on languages, with 20 storefront languages on its Premium plan. Shoppers save and share in their own language, so a store selling in several markets gets one wishlist for all of them. Its developer also offers custom button designs. Pick it if your storefront is multilingual and saving is all you need.

Key features:

• A save button and a wishlist page shoppers can share with friends
• An animated button, custom icons and custom layouts (Basic plan)
• Reports (Basic plan) and full statistics (Premium plan)
• 2, 7 or 20 storefront languages, by plan
• Works with Shopify customer accounts

Pros:

• 20 storefront languages on Premium
• Custom button designs by the developer

Cons:

• 7,000 wishlist additions a month on Basic
• No shopper emails that we could find
• No help docs or wishlist export that we could find
• Focuses on saving and sharing

Pricing:

SoluCommerce's website shows no prices, so these come from the Shopify App Store listing on October 16, 2026. There's no free trial.

Alternatives: 7 Best SWishlist App Alternatives for Shopify

6. Hulk AI Wishlist & Favorites

Best for: Stores with a wholesale side or a shop counter that need wishlists in POS and at B2B prices

Rating: 4.9 (141 reviews) | App type: Standalone | Free trial: 14 days | Built for Shopify: Yes

Hulk AI Wishlist & Favorites, previously Hulk Advanced Wishlist, is a Shopify app for wishlists, shopper emails and in-store lists. The headline feature is reach, with wishlists in Shopify POS, Shopify Flow and HulkApps' B2B wholesale app. Counter staff and wholesale buyers see the same saved items, so one list follows the shopper wherever they buy. It also emails shoppers about price drops, restocks and low stock. It works well for stores that sell in person or to wholesale buyers.

Key features:

• Multiple wishlist boards (Growth plan) that shoppers can use as gift lists
• Save for Later on the cart page
• Shared lists where a friend can choose a variant and buy it
• Timed reminders plus back-in-stock, price-drop and low-stock emails with editable templates
• AI-written reminder email text and AI product recommendations on the wishlist page
• A public wishlist counter on products
• Shopify POS (Pro plan) and Shopify Flow (Growth plan)
• Wholesale prices on wishlists through Wholesale Pricing Discount B2B
• Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Omnisend, Zapier and Google Sheets connections

Pros:

• Shopper emails without a separate alerts app
• More than one list per shopper
• AI help with email copy
• CSV import and export

Cons:

• Saving switches off once the monthly item quota is passed, until the store upgrades
• Focuses on wishlists and wishlist emails
• A June 2025 reviewer found its script on every page of the store
• Tracking tags that broke Google Tag Manager, per the same review

Pricing:

Prices from hulkapps.com on October 16, 2026, with a 14-day free trial. We used the website's table; the App Store listing shows only Growth, Pro and Scale.

Alternatives: 8 Best Hulk AI Wishlist & Favorites App Alternatives for Shopify

7. Wishlist ‑ Wishify

Best for: Stores whose shoppers pass wishlists around on WhatsApp

Rating: 4.9 (218 reviews) | App type: Standalone | Free trial: 7 days | Built for Shopify: Yes

Wishlist ‑ Wishify is a Shopify app from Zooomy for a small wishlist with sharing and reminders. Its main draw is sharing, with lists sent over WhatsApp, email, Facebook and Twitter. Shoppers pass a list to friends and family in the apps they already use, so a saved product reaches more possible buyers. Its Advanced plan adds automatic reminder emails. It's made for stores whose customers swap gift ideas on WhatsApp.

Key features:

• A product page button and a wishlist link in the main menu
• A collection widget and a header heart (Professional plan)
• Guest saves (Professional plan)
• Sharing over email, Facebook, WhatsApp and Twitter (Professional plan)
• Reminder emails sent automatically (Advanced plan)
• Data export (Professional plan) and full reports (Premium plan)

Pros:

• Reminder emails that go out on their own, on the Advanced plan
• Sharing over WhatsApp as well as email and social apps
• Long-time users still rate it well after five to seven years

Cons:

• Every plan limits wishlist items a month
• Guest saves start on the Professional plan
• Focuses on the wishlist
• Zooomy's restock alerts are a separate install

Pricing:

Zooomyapps.com lists no prices, so these are from the Shopify App Store listing on October 16, 2026, with a 7-day free trial.

Alternatives: 8 Best Wishlist ‑ Wishify App Alternatives for Shopify

How Many Apps Each Option Replaces

Every app you install can add its own code to your storefront, and that code affects load time. The table below shows how many separate apps each option replaces, based on our count.

Here's what each option replaces:

• Vitals - All in One App: 40+ apps, including a wishlist app, a back-in-stock app, an email and push marketing app, a pop-up app and a recently viewed app
• Wishlist Hero: a wishlist app and a price-drop and low-stock email app
• Wishlist by Flits: a wishlist app and a Notify Me restock app
• Swish (Wishlist King): a wishlist app and, with Klaviyo, a wishlist alert app
• SWishlist: Simple Wishlist: a wishlist app for saving and sharing
• Hulk AI Wishlist & Favorites: a wishlist app, a wishlist email app and a save-for-later app
• Wishlist ‑ Wishify: a wishlist app plus reminder emails
• Wishlist by Square: a wishlist app

Say you use the Wishlist by Square app with a back-in-stock app, an email marketing app and a recently viewed app. That's four apps loading four scripts. With Vitals, you can replace all four apps with one subscription.

When Should You Stay on Wishlist by Square?

The Wishlist by Square app is still the better choice if:

• You only need a wishlist and want to pay nothing for it, with every feature on the free plan
• You want the highest-rated wishlist app here among those with more than 100 reviews

On the other hand, switch to Vitals if you want restock alerts by email or text next to the wishlist, with review stars on each saved product. Email and push campaigns and a recently viewed carousel come in the same subscription too.

How to Migrate From Wishlist by Square

The Wishlist by Square app stores your shoppers' saved lists, so export them before you remove it.

1. Export the CSV of every saved item from the Wishlist by Square app, so you keep the shopper, login status, product, variant and date of each save
2. Send the file to the Vitals team, so they can import it into Vitals Wishlist App. Guest lists kept only in browser cookies can't move
3. Install Vitals - All in One App and duplicate your live theme, so you can set things up without changing the live store
4. Turn on Vitals Wishlist App and Vitals Back in Stock App on the duplicate theme, then match the hearts, button and header icon to your current setup
5. Turn on Vitals Product Reviews App if you want stars on the wishlist page
6. Switch off the Wishlist by Square app embed in the theme editor, so shoppers see only one set of hearts
7. Test saving, sharing and adding every saved item to the cart on desktop and mobile, then publish the theme
8. Uninstall the Wishlist by Square app last

Where Each Wishlist by Square Feature Goes in Vitals

For example, Crystal Pro Jewellery replaced 7 single-purpose apps with one Vitals subscription.

Read: Best All in One Apps for Shopify in 2026

Find the Best Wishlist by Square Alternative for Your Store

Vitals - All in One App is the best fit for most stores, but the right pick depends on why you're leaving the Wishlist by Square app.

• Vitals - All in One App, if you want a wishlist, restock alerts by email or text, email and push campaigns, and 40+ apps in one subscription from $29.99/month
• Wishlist Hero, if you want price-drop emails and wishlist events in your ad pixels
• Wishlist by Flits, if shoppers save specific variants and you want restock emails in the same app
• Swish (Wishlist King), if Klaviyo sends your email and should send wishlist alerts too
• SWishlist: Simple Wishlist, if you sell in many languages and saving is all you need
• Hulk AI Wishlist & Favorites, if wishlists need to reach your POS or your wholesale buyers
• Wishlist ‑ Wishify, if your shoppers share lists on WhatsApp

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the best Wishlist by Square alternative for Shopify?

Vitals - All in One App is the best Wishlist by Square alternative for most stores. No other app here puts 40+ apps, such as a wishlist, back-in-stock alerts and product reviews, in one subscription. Since Vitals is our app, we've listed its limitations in its review above.

2. How do Vitals and Wishlist by Square compare on wishlist features?

Both offer hearts on product cards, an Add to Wishlist button, a header icon, guest wishlists, sharing, a wishlist page and CSV export. Only the Wishlist by Square app comes free, with every feature on one plan. Vitals, on the other hand, includes review stars on the wishlist page, back-in-stock alerts by email or text and a recently viewed carousel, plus the rest of its 40+ apps.

3. Which Wishlist by Square alternatives send emails to shoppers?

Not all of them. Wishlist Hero sends price-drop and low-stock emails. Hulk AI Wishlist & Favorites sends reminder, restock, price-drop and low-stock emails. Swish sends alerts through Klaviyo, and Wishlist by Flits sends back-in-stock emails. Wishify sends reminder emails on its Advanced plan, and Vitals sends restock alerts by email or text through Vitals Back in Stock App. SWishlist doesn't list shopper emails, and neither does the Wishlist by Square app.

4. Can Vitals replace Wishlist by Square and other apps at the same time?

Yes, for most stores. Vitals can replace the Wishlist by Square app's hearts, save button, guest wishlists, sharing, wishlist page and CSV export. It can also replace separate apps for back-in-stock alerts, email and push marketing and recently viewed products.

5. How do these Wishlist by Square alternatives affect store speed?

Each app you install can add its own scripts to your storefront. That means speed depends on how many apps you have, not just which ones. Vitals - All in One App serves its wishlist, back-in-stock alerts and recently viewed carousel from one script. If you use several single-purpose apps instead, each one loads its own script. We didn't speed-test these apps, so check your own pages before and after a change.

6. Which Wishlist by Square alternatives have AI features or MCP support?

Not all of them. With Vitals MCP, Claude or ChatGPT can tell you which products shoppers save most. Hulk AI Wishlist & Favorites writes reminder email text with AI and recommends products on the wishlist page. Wishlist Hero, Flits, Swish, SWishlist and Wishify list no AI features or MCP support, and neither does the Wishlist by Square app.

7. How do I migrate from Wishlist by Square to Vitals?

Export the CSV of saved items from the Wishlist by Square app. Send it to the Vitals team, who can import it into Vitals Wishlist App. On a duplicate theme, switch on Vitals Wishlist App and Vitals Back in Stock App. Switch off the Wishlist by Square app embed and test saving and sharing. Uninstall the Wishlist by Square app last.